This chapter considers the role of ideas and discourse in European integration from the perspective of discursive institutionalism, which focuses on the substantive content of ideas and the interactive processes of discourse in institutional context. The chapter explores the importance of ideas and discourse in the actual processes of European integration as well as in scholarly analyses of the nature, scope, and processes of European integration. It begins with the ideas and discourse of analysts and actors regarding what the EU is and what it should become, it follows with how they conceptualize the drivers of European integration, then how they deal with questions of legitimacy in the EU, and ends with an in-depth exploration of ideas and discourse related to the Eurozone crisis and its impact on member state policy and politics.
Vivien A. Schmidt
Discursive institutionalism is an umbrella concept for approaches that concern themselves with the substantive content of ideas and the interactive processes of discourse in institutional context. This chapter shows the relevance of discursive institutionalism to policy studies in a critical vein by considering both the wide range of ideas in discourse and the ways in which ‘sentient’ (thinking and speaking) agents articulate such ideas as policy actors in a ‘coordinative discourse’ of policy construction and as political actors in a ‘communicative discourse’ of political legitimation. The chapter also elaborates on the dual nature of the institutional context by considering not just the external formalized institutions that constrain action but also the structures and constructs of meaning. These help explain not only how agents are able to create and maintain institutions via their ‘background ideational abilities’ but also how they change or maintain institutions via their ‘foreground discursive abilities’ of communication. But although meaning is socially constructed, the chapter builds on the work of Wittgenstein to show that this does not lead to radical relativism because knowledge comes with different kinds of certainty. Finally, the chapter also theorizes about the nature of the power of ideas, in particular through discourse.